Supreme Court Set to Rule on Edo Governorship Election Tomorrow
The very contentious Edo State gubernatorial election that took place on September 21, 2024, is about to get a historic ruling from the Nigerian Supreme Court tomorrow, July 2, 2025. Asue Ighodalo, a candidate for the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), has consistently challenged the election results, and the current governor of Edo State, Monday Okpebholo, is an APC, but the ruling of the supreme court will be the last word in a legal dispute that has engulfed Edo State politics for months.
After a closely fought 2024 Edo gubernatorial election, Senator Monday Okpebholo was declared the winner with 291,667 votes by the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC). Olumide Akpata of the Labour Party came in last with 22,763 votes, while his nearest opponent, Asue Ighodalo of the PDP, received 247,274 votes.
Ighodalo and the PDP wasted little time in submitting a petition to the Edo State Governorship Election Petition Tribunal after the announcement, in which they claimed that there had been extensive over-voting and serious violations of the Electoral Act. They said the election's legitimacy was called into question since ward-level results did not match those announced at the voting stations.
The Election Petition Tribunal rejected Ighodalo and the PDP's petition on April 2, 2025, due to its lack of merit. The tribunal determined that the petitioners' allegations of over-voting and non-compliance were not supported by reliable evidence. The lead verdict was delivered by Justice Wilfred Kpochi, who stressed that the claimed voting irregularities were not proven by calling relevant witnesses. The panel also found that the petitioners’ case crumbled owing to inadequate evidence, recognizing Okpebholo’s triumph as legitimate and genuine.
Unsatisfied, Ighodalo and the PDP appealed to the Court of Appeal in Abuja. However, on May 29, 2025, a three-member court headed by Justice Mohammed Danjuma unanimously affirmed the tribunal’s ruling. The petitioners had not shown a miscarriage of justice and had not presented reliable evidence to back their claims, thus the appeals court rejected their case. Justice Danjuma characterized the appeal as lacking substance and advised the petitioners to accept the result.
Despite the failures at the tribunal and appellate levels, Asue Ighodalo has promised to take the dispute to the Supreme Court, Nigeria’s highest legal body. He claims that the lower courts neglected to address the "grave concerns" surrounding widespread breaches of the Electoral Act and electoral non-compliance. Ighodalo’s legal team says that the ruling confirms a dangerous practice of electoral impunity, which undermines public faith in Nigeria’s democratic process.
The Supreme Court’s decision is eagerly awaited as it will clarify whether the concurrent rulings of the tribunal and Court of Appeal hold or whether the Supreme Court will find reasons to reject the election results. The case also bears similarities with a recent 2020 Supreme Court verdict on the Imo State gubernatorial election, when the top court overruled lower court rulings owing to omitted votes from several polling units. Legal experts are carefully waiting to see whether the Edo case will take a similar course or maintain the lower courts’ judgments.
Governor Monday Okpebholo and his allies have asked the opposition to accept the Court of Appeal’s verdict and concentrate on administration and development in Edo State. Okpebholo’s side argues that the election was free, fair, and legitimate and that the court has previously recognized the legality of his mandate. An advisor to the governor recently disputed allegations that the cabinet formation was being postponed until the Supreme Court verdict, underlining that the government continued uninterrupted.
Conversely, the PDP and Ighodalo’s supporters are confident that the Supreme Court would bring justice by properly analyzing the evidence of alleged election malpractices. They contend that the integrity of Edo State’s election process and the larger democratic system in Nigeria rely on a brave and unbiased verdict by the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court’s ruling would have far-reaching repercussions not just for Edo State but also for Nigeria’s election jurisprudence. A verdict in favor of Ighodalo might lead to a nullification of the 2024 election results and either a rerun or a proclamation of the PDP candidate as governor, depending on the court’s findings. On the other side, an affirmation of Okpebholo’s win would confirm the rulings of the lower courts and solidify the APC’s grip on Edo State.
The case also exposes persistent issues in Nigeria’s electoral system, including charges of over-voting, non-compliance with electoral regulations, and the role of the court in settling election disputes. The Supreme Court’s handling of this case will be widely examined as a test of Nigeria’s adherence to democratic ideals and the rule of law.
As the Supreme Court prepares to hear the Edo gubernatorial election appeal tomorrow, all eyes will be on the highest court to give a ruling that might impact the political landscape of Edo State and establish a precedent for future electoral conflicts in Nigeria. The verdict will either provide a resolution to a prolonged legal struggle or prolong political uncertainty, emphasizing the important role of the court in defending Nigeria’s democracy.
The people of Edo State and Nigeria at large await a ruling that supports justice, transparency, and the integrity of the democratic process. The Supreme Court’s ruling will not only choose the future governor of Edo State but also confirm the strength and independence of Nigeria’s democratic institutions.